Why is pxg controversial

Content on WhatAnswers is provided "as is" for informational purposes. While we strive for accuracy, we make no guarantees. Content is AI-assisted and should not be used as professional advice.

Last updated: April 8, 2026

Quick Answer: During the month of Ramadan, observant Muslims abstain from eating, drinking, and other physical needs from dawn until sunset. This fast, known as Sawm, is one of the five pillars of Islam and is broken after sunset with the Iftar meal.

Key Facts

Fasting during Ramadan excludes drinking any liquids, including water, from dawn (Fajr) to sunset (Maghrib).
The fast is broken with the Iftar meal after sunset, where water can be consumed.
Hydration is crucial during non-fasting hours to maintain health and energy levels.
Suhoor, the pre-dawn meal, is another opportunity to drink water and hydrate.
Exceptions to the fast exist for individuals with certain health conditions, pregnant or breastfeeding women, and travelers, though these are often subject to specific religious guidelines and atonement.

Overview

Ramadan is a sacred month observed by Muslims worldwide, characterized by fasting, prayer, reflection, and community. It is a time for spiritual growth and self-discipline, where adherents aim to draw closer to God. A cornerstone of Ramadan is the observance of the fast, known as Sawm, which involves abstaining from food, drink, and other physical needs from dawn until sunset each day. This practice is a fundamental pillar of Islam, intended to foster empathy for the less fortunate, purify the soul, and strengthen one's connection with the Divine.

The question of whether water can be consumed during Ramadan is central to understanding the practice of fasting. The general rule of Sawm dictates a complete abstinence from all liquids, including water, during the daylight hours. This period of abstention, from the first light of dawn (Fajr) until the setting of the sun (Maghrib), is meticulously followed by those who are able. However, the observance is not absolute, with specific provisions for certain individuals and times outside the fasting window.

How It Works

The Fasting Period (Sawm): The daily fast begins before sunrise and ends at sunset. During this time, consuming any food or drink, including water, is prohibited. This strict abstinence is meant to instill discipline and a heightened awareness of one's reliance on God and the blessings of sustenance. The intention behind the fast is as important as the act itself, focusing on spiritual purification and empathy.
Breaking the Fast (Iftar): The fast is broken after sunset with a meal called Iftar. This is a communal and often joyous occasion where families and communities gather to share food and drink. Water is permitted and is often the first thing consumed to rehydrate the body after a day without fluids. Dates are traditionally eaten first, followed by water, before the main meal.
Pre-Dawn Meal (Suhoor): Before the commencement of the fast each day, a meal known as Suhoor is consumed. This meal is taken in the early morning hours, before dawn. It is crucial for providing energy and hydration to sustain the individual throughout the fasting day. Drinking plenty of water during Suhoor is highly recommended to combat thirst.
Exceptions and Exemptions: While the fast is a core tenet, Islam recognizes that certain individuals may be unable to observe it fully due to health reasons, age, or specific life circumstances. This includes the sick, the elderly, pregnant or breastfeeding women, menstruating women, and travelers. In such cases, individuals may be exempt from fasting and may need to make up the missed days later or offer a compensatory act (Fidya), such as feeding a poor person for each day missed.

Key Comparisons

Aspect	During Fasting Hours (Dawn to Sunset)	Outside Fasting Hours (Sunset to Dawn)
Water Consumption	Not Permitted	Permitted
Food Consumption	Not Permitted	Permitted
Spiritual Focus	Heightened	Sustained

Why It Matters

Health and Well-being: Proper hydration during the non-fasting hours (from sunset to dawn) is paramount. The human body requires a significant amount of water to function optimally. Consuming sufficient water during Iftar and Suhoor helps prevent dehydration, headaches, fatigue, and other adverse health effects that can arise from not drinking fluids for extended periods.
Spiritual Discipline and Empathy: The abstinence from water, like food, is a deliberate act of self-control. It teaches individuals to be mindful of their desires and to exercise patience. Furthermore, by experiencing thirst, Muslims are encouraged to empathize with those who suffer from water scarcity and hunger globally, fostering a sense of compassion and charity (Zakat).
Community and Reflection: Ramadan is a time for strengthening community bonds. The shared experience of fasting, breaking the fast together at Iftar, and congregational prayers (Tarawih) fosters a sense of unity. It also provides ample opportunity for personal reflection, increased prayer, and reading the Quran, further deepening one's spiritual connection.

In conclusion, while drinking water is strictly prohibited during the daylight hours of Ramadan's fast, it is an essential and permitted part of the non-fasting periods. The sacred month of Ramadan emphasizes a balance between spiritual discipline and the physical needs of the body. Observant Muslims focus on consuming adequate water during Suhoor and Iftar to maintain their health and energy, while dedicating the fasting hours to spiritual growth and empathy.